November 2026: NEET Zero: Are We Counting Everyone? The Traveller Movement Responds to the Milburn Review

Nearly one million young people are outside education, employment and training. Before we blame them, we should check the facts.

19 Nov 2026

By The Traveller Movement

Nearly one million young people are outside education, employment and training. Before we blame them, we should check the facts.

The government has published Alan Milburn’s review, From a Welfare State to a Working State, setting out a ten-year ambition towards “NEET Zero” and full participation for young people by 2036.

Alongside this, the government is expanding its Jobs Guarantee, aiming to support more than 90,000 eligible young people into fully funded six-month jobs by March 2029.

There is much to welcome here. The ambition is right. But ambition also deserves scrutiny.

The context is sobering. The review itself points out that only Romania has a higher NEET rate than the UK in Europe. Britain has a serious problem with young people becoming disconnected from education and employment. But that does not necessarily mean the standard explanation for why this is happening is right.

Four questions matter.

1. Is the “welfare crisis” what we are told?

The UK’s welfare bill, including pensions, was £314.9 billion in 2024/25, or 10.7% of GDP, and is forecast to reach around 11.2% by 2030/31. Comparisons with European social protection spending need to be made carefully because countries account for health, welfare and social provision differently. But they do reinforce an important point: claims about Britain having an exceptional welfare-spending problem need proper, like-for-like scrutiny.

A substantial proportion of UK social security spending goes to pensioners. At the same time, health-related barriers among people of working age are becoming increasingly significant. So when young people’s benefits are presented as part of a fiscal emergency, we should pause.

Worsening health is real. This is not simply a story about a generation that has stopped trying.

2. Will paying young people’s wages work?

The Jobs Guarantee offers eligible 18–24-year-olds on Universal Credit a fully funded six-month job, with government funding for up to 25 hours a week at the relevant minimum wage. Alan Milburn goes further, recommending a package of youth hiring incentives worth around £1.1 billion a year once fully scaled up.

There is real potential here. But we should learn from the past. The Youth Training Scheme of the 1980s also subsidised young people’s labour. Critics argued that some employers benefited from subsidised workers without providing meaningful progression or sustained employment afterwards.

This scheme is different. Young people receive a real wage and there is wraparound support. But the risks of churn, substitution and temporary employment remain. Success should not simply be measured by how many young people enter a six-month placement. It should be measured by where those young people are six months, a year and two years later.

The review identifies around 314,000 NEET young people who are outside the benefit system altogether. If the principal route into employment support depends upon benefit eligibility, how do we reach those young people?

3. Are we demonising mental ill health?

The Fonagy Review provides important context. ADHD and autism are neurodevelopmental conditions, and rising levels of mental distress and poor mental health among children and young people cannot simply be dismissed as lifestyle choices or lack of motivation.

Between 2015 and 2025, the proportion of NEET young people reporting a work-limiting health condition rose from 26% to 44%. Mental health conditions and autism account for more than two-thirds of NEET young people who report poor health as preventing them from working. Hundreds of thousands of people are also waiting for ADHD and autism assessments.

There are welcome elements within Alan Milburn’s health proposals, including additional protection for people with the most severe and complex needs. But support cannot be reserved only for people who cross the highest threshold of disability. If young people are genuinely ill, waiting for diagnosis or struggling without appropriate support, reform must help them move forward rather than punish them for being stuck in the system.

4. Are there better doors to open?

Perhaps one of the most important findings in the review is also one of the simplest: young people want opportunities. The review found that 73% of NEET respondents wanted to move into employment, education or training, and 52% wanted to do so as soon as possible. That should challenge the idea that young people have simply chosen not to participate.

It also argues for investment in community-rooted youth work and local opportunities, rather than relying solely on employer subsidies. The Enterprise Allowance Scheme gave unemployed people financial support while they established their own businesses. Hundreds of thousands participated, with beneficiaries associated with businesses and organisations including Superdry and Creation Records.

As our economy changes, why not consider a modern version? Start-up grants. Mentoring. Skills development. Community enterprise. Support for young people who want to create their own employment rather than simply enter a short-term placement. For some communities, that could be transformational.

And this matters enormously for Romani (Gypsy), Roma and Irish Traveller young people

At The Traveller Movement, we know that the journey towards becoming NEET often starts much earlier. Our Fought Not Taught research documents experiences of bullying, discrimination, punitive school practices and what we have described as “institutionally coerced exclusion”. Official data consistently show exceptionally high exclusion and absence rates among pupils recorded within Gypsy/Roma and Irish Traveller categories.

Our Roads to Success work has also highlighted some of the poorest education and employment outcomes in the UK, alongside serious inequalities in mental health. But statistics still do not adequately capture the experiences of Romani (Gypsy), Roma and Irish Traveller young people. If people are not properly counted, it becomes much easier for policy to overlook them.

If access to a Jobs Guarantee relies heavily on mainstream employers, digital systems and benefit eligibility, there is a danger that some of the young people furthest from opportunity will once again be missed. Self-employment, trading, family businesses and enterprise also have deep roots across many Gypsy, Roma and Traveller communities. For some young people, the right route may not be a six-month placement with a large employer. It might be support to develop a trade, build a business or turn existing skills into sustainable employment. Policy should be flexible enough to open both doors.

At The Traveller Movement, these are not abstract policy questions. Through our education, employment, advocacy and criminal justice work, we see how exclusion from school, discrimination and a lack of culturally appropriate support can close down opportunities long before somebody is labelled “NEET”. Our research and engagement with communities continually point towards the importance of earlier intervention, better ethnic monitoring, meaningful community involvement, and employment and enterprise routes that reflect young people’s actual lives.

The Traveller Movement would welcome the opportunity to advise government and work directly with those responsible for implementing the Youth and Jobs Guarantees, bringing our evidence, community insight and practical experience to help ensure Romani (Gypsy), Roma and Irish Traveller young people are properly counted, consulted and included in their design, delivery and evaluation.

The bottom line

Alan Milburn’s diagnosis is stark, but the ambition behind the review is right. The real test will be delivery:

  • What happens to young people after their six-month placement?
  • How do we reach the hundreds of thousands outside the benefit system?
  • How do we support young people facing genuine health barriers?
  • Where is the route into enterprise and self-employment?
  • And will Romani (Gypsy), Roma and Irish Traveller young people finally be properly counted and included?

Alan Milburn met hundreds of young people and said he did not find one who wanted to be NEET.

As one young woman told him, young people are “desperate for education, employment and training.”

The least we owe them is honesty about the numbers and opportunities built for them, not around them.